Shahid Kapoor recently stirred up a storm on the internet with his comment about his 2007 hit film Jab We Met. The actor said that his character, Aditya, wouldn’t have put up with Geet (played by Kareena Kapoor) today because “she’s her own favourite.” The remark has since gone viral, and fans have been quick to respond, many of them criticizing him for his take on the beloved characters.
In a recent interview with The Indian Express, Shahid was asked about director Imtiaz Ali’s statement that Geet and Aditya would likely be at a divorce lawyer’s office today. Shahid, rather than disagreeing, played along and called it a “fascinating idea.” He explained that no one would be able to tolerate a character like Geet, who “loves herself more than anyone else.” His comment seemed to rub fans the wrong way, and social media was soon filled with reactions, with many disappointed by his words.
Some fans were quick to point out that Geet’s character was much more than just someone who focused on herself. One user noted, “She loved Anshuman more than herself, remember? She was obsessed with him, even though he left her. That’s not someone who’s all about herself.” Another fan humorously commented that Shahid’s remark was aimed at his ex-girlfriend, Kareena Kapoor, suggesting that the actor was indirectly referring to their own past relationship.
The internet quickly took sides. Many users expressed disbelief at Shahid’s statement, with some even suggesting that he was more like Kabir Singh, his character from the 2019 film Kabir Singh, than Aditya from Jab We Met. The comparison is based on how both characters are possessive and somewhat toxic in their relationships. One social media user jokingly wrote, “Shahid is more Kabir Singh than Aditya in real life!”
Other reactions pointed to Shahid’s personal life and his past relationship with Kareena Kapoor, which ended around the time Jab We Met was released. Some fans were quick to bring up Kareena’s relationship with Saif Ali Khan, saying that she made a smarter choice by moving on to someone who suited her life goals better. “Geet wouldn’t have stayed with Aditya. She’s smarter than that,” said one user. “Kareena dodged a bullet and got her nawab. Shahid’s just bitter.”
There were also those who couldn’t help but laugh at Shahid’s remark, even calling for a sequel to the film. “Why not make Jab We Divorced now? It would be interesting to see how Aditya and Geet handle life after marriage,” wrote another fan, clearly amused by the possibility.
Despite the criticism, Shahid did try to clarify his stance. He mentioned that since Imtiaz Ali created the characters and vision for Jab We Met, he, as an actor, didn’t have much to say about the direction the story might take in today’s world. He suggested that the characters had been written in a particular context for the time they were created, but admitted that things might be different now.
For those who grew up watching Jab We Met, this movie holds a special place. It’s known for its fun, quirky characters and its message about self-love and personal growth. Aditya and Geet’s relationship might have had its ups and downs, but it was all part of the charm. Fans were hoping for a light-hearted take on the film’s characters, not a reminder that relationships sometimes don’t last.
The online debate only proves how deeply Jab We Met has resonated with its audience. Shahid’s comments, although playful, have reignited fans’ connection to the movie. While some are upset, others are still clinging to the hope that Geet and Aditya’s love story would have had a happy ending—at least in their heads. It looks like the Jab We Met debate is far from over.
